Dr Leaf is not licensed to give medical or psychological advice of any kind 10. Ps Dennis Clark and Dr Jennifer Clark I dont really know anything about them or their work. Dr Leaf holds a 20-year old PhD as a sub-specialist speech pathologist. Caroline Leaf is a cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in Communication Pathology specializing in Neuropsychology. Cussenot, O. and Valeri, A., Heterogeneity in genetic susceptibility to prostate cancer. I think theres a lot of information out there on epigenetics thats been misrepresented by alternative health practitioners and by people like Dr Leaf, which is best summarised by this paragraph, and indeed, this blog post: In the end, what is most concerning about the hype of epigenetics is how it feeds into what Ive referred to (ironically, of course) as the central dogma of CAM: Namely The Secret. The more people that hear your concerns, the better. Mr Mac Leaf, the husband of Dr Caroline Leaf, kindly took the time to respond to my series of posts on the teachings of Dr Leaf at Kings Christian Centre, on the Gold Coast, Australia, earlier this month. Thank you for your research and information. But lets also avoid an unkind legalism that puts unfair burdens on struggling people. Leaf is also the bestselling author of Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess, Think Learn Succeed, Think and Eat Yourself Smart, and many more. She was one of the first in her field to study how the brain can change (neuroplasticity) with directed mind input. NOTE: This is NOT a substitute. Not for the sake of us, but for others that do not know HIM! As I had intended, and as Mr Leaf requested, I published his reply, complete and unabridged (here). So, I wrote to Professor Howard Gardner who still works at Harvard University. Chesapeake, Virginia 23320 I know my path. It does not determine our health. For years, Dr. Caroline Leaf has traveled the globe as an author and public speaker examining many aspects of the neuroscience world. They did not prove that toxic thoughts cause depression. What about a baby that dies of SIDS? WebDr. Most of us will never gain expertise from listening to you or to Caroline.. This, in turn, impacts the way our body functions by impeding our ability to get nutrients from our food, which can set us up for all sorts of diseases (for more on the gut-brain connection, see my recent blogand podcast). Dr Leaf has categorically stated that 75 to 98% of all illnesses are the result of our thought life on a number of occasions. Kunes, J. and Zicha, J., The interaction of genetic and environmental factors in the etiology of hypertension. As you have heard me say many times before, how we choose to use our brains affects both our mental and physical health. I am sure a practitioner like you has to invest quite a bit o energy to keep up even for you! He developed the Human Papilloma Virus vaccine and was the 2006 Australian of the Year. . iBooks AU = https://itunes.apple.com/au/book/kintsukuroi-christians/id1231172522?mt=11, Hold that thought: Reappraising the work of Dr Caroline Leaf = https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/466848. Study 1s findings suggested that these 20 questions forming the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) survey tool have both structural validity and consistent reliability across both samples. You will also be able to rethink your reaction to the information, evaluating how the thought you are working on is changing, and then reconceptualizing it by looking for patterns and triggers (little by little, day by day). After more discussion with my husband, I felt I needed to see what others were saying about Dr. 9. DISCLAIMER You can also get 20% off your order of BiOptimizers atwww.bioptimizers.com/drleafwith the coupon code: DRLEAF20) to keep my gut-brain connection in perfect health, and my evening cup of organic herbalPiquetea before bed (Get up to 20% off your organic Pique Tea order and FREE shipping atpiquetea.life/drleaf). If this is true, then the brain is pre-wired for both optimism and love, but also fear. Reiki works well for some people. http://www.equip.org/article/an-unpersuasive-paradigm/. and had even contacted him as a matter of courtesy and offered a free book then I would have felt different! Mental training via deep thinking and understanding to build memory and learning actually increases the numbers of neurons that develop in the brain, particularly when the training goals are challenging. Caroline Leaf has spent the last 30 years researching the mind-brain connection, nature of mental health and formation of memory. And I certainly dont feel she is deceptive or just in it for the money. 2013 [cited 2013 Aug 22]; Available from: http://www.theverge.com/2013/8/21/4595712/gut-feelings-the-future-of-psychiatry-may-be-inside-your-stomach. Sleepis like the street-sweeper of the body, and is essential when it comes to our brain health. I am not an academic, nor a scientist or considered intellectual, but doesnt the new information on epigenetics confirm a lot of her theories? You raise some very interesting points, some of which are certainly reasonable assumptions and observations. If the mind controls the brain and not the other way around as Dr Leaf suggests, why do some people with acquired brain injuries or brain tumours develop acute personality changes or thought disorders? The researchers conducted face and content validity assessments to ensure a strong initial approach to question selection. Mara, D., et al., Sanitation and health. Teacher Survey (Steiner & Woo, 2021) have revealed that job-related stresses, which have been amplified with COVID-19 measures, are critically threatening the teacher supply. Circulation, 2009. 11. (LogOut/ If youre interested, I suggest that you review chapter 1, specifically the section The Neuroscience of Thought (http://www.debunkingdrleaf.com/chapter-1/), chapter 6 (http://www.debunkingdrleaf.com/chapter-6/), chapter 8 (http://www.debunkingdrleaf.com/chapter-8/) and chapter 10 (http://www.debunkingdrleaf.com/chapter-10/). Thank you very much. PROSTATE There are only two risk factors for prostate cancer, familial aggregation and ethnic origin. I just finished module 1 training with Dr. Caroline Leaf to become a certified Neurocycle facilitator (inaugural class of 2022). document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. And while there are many leaders in the evangelical movement who are preaching a false gospel, we need to be careful not to lump all unconventional teachers in together and call them guilty by association. 11. I really appreciate how Dr. As I said before, chronic long term stress is not caused by wrong thinking. I guess you would have to find an audience of people who are interested in hearing the various opinions. Number of occasion? I think it is tragic that most doctors as well as many in the church do not see the strong influence that our thinking has on our health. Each communication contains a URL that participants use to gain access to the survey. Thank you for your comment. WebSince the early 1980's, Dr. Is that someone who is gracious, humble or teachable? and helps me maintain a healthy sleep schedule even when I travel. The lord directs us to hold teachers and preachers up to Gods word? 18. When it comes to sleep, remember to avoid panicking when you cant fall sleep. The national study of NeurocycleTM app users is a longitudinal multi-year study aimed to assess the impact of the NeurocycleTM program on pro-mindfulness factors including resilience, gratitude, autonomy, hope, confidence, and the behavior to think, feel, and choose positive mental perspectives by measuring changes in the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) Scales (autonomy, awareness, toxic thoughts and isolation, toxic stress and anxiety, barriers and challenges, empowerment and life satisfaction) among U.S. adults ages 18 to 80 who use the NeurocycleTM app program. There is so much more evidence. , Please note, comments must be approved before they are published. Theres no stepping down going on here. These moments give your brain a rest and allow it to reboot and heal, which increases your clarity of mind and ability to problem-solve when face with a tough situation. Your rebuttal is not sound! So just relax, tell yourself you will eventually sleep, do something constructive, and make a plan to catch up on your sleep over the next few days. WebDr. Google Scholar did not display any articles that had cited it, which must be an error on Googles part. Creativity, whether we are talking about music, painting, writing, drawing, poetry and so on, can have real, positive effects on the physical health of the brain and on our overall mental health, and has the potential to heal damage from toxic thinking and toxic lifestyles. Teacher Survey (Steiner & Woo, 2021) have revealed that job-related stresses, which have been amplified with COVID-19 measures, are critically threatening the teacher supply. 13(4): 463-74. It is known there are stress hormones /cortisol that can have a negative affect on ones health. Since the early 1980s she has studied and researched the In her latest blog post, Dr Caroline Leaf attempted to tackle the complex topic of Alzheimer disease. Just as CCK excretion does not cause us all to have panic attacks every time we eat, ANP does not provide anxiolysis in normal day to day situations. As you heard, she brags a lot about how amazing her research is, when in reality theres actually no objective evidence that its actually helped anyone. Youre more than welcome to disagree with the conclusions I draw but I disagree that it is unsound. Globally, mental health concerns are growing. And so on so on! Here I have been trying to fill my head with Dr. Caroline Leafs teachings thinking and believing that her research is the new breakthrough information I have been searching for, yet all the while having this nagging sense of discomfort due to her affiliation with Kenneth Copeland ministries and here, thank God, is an educated, confident Believer just putting it out there as it should be truthful and straightforward. Systems, settings, people: Workforce development challenges for the alcohol and other drugs field, 2001: 93-107. Why show the world we are no better than the pagans ~ We are to show we are Christians by our love (no doubt theyre red letters John 13:33-35). Thanks for the comment. PLoS Genet, 2013. on The data collection protocol begins with an email invitation, and non-responders are contacted up to three times by email reminders spaced by 5-7 days each. In the interests of healthy public debate, and encouraging people to make their own informed decisions on the teachings of Dr Leaf, any comments regarding the response of Mr Leaf, Dr Leaf or myself, are welcome provided they are constructive. Its an absolute hoot. Thanks to both Dr. Caroline Leaf (and her husband), Dr. C Edward Pitt and others for openly stating your research and opinions. Users are invited and reminded to participate in the survey via emails. Leaf. its always about the money. Its like if she uses scientific language and talks really fast that no one will notice. Most importantly, take the time to examine your thought life; a chaotic mind will affect your quality of sleep and how much you sleep. 23. on I am 40 years old. Long ago I am engaged in significant discussion with him and reviewed his apparent being removed out devotion to targeting Caroline with arguments that are rarely understood by anyone except him. Sid just accepted such a bogus statement as fact without batting an eyelid. I dont seek your agreement or approval. One can only conclude that there is a bi-directional effect between the brain and the stream of thought, which is at odds with Dr Leafs statement that the mind controls the brain and not the other way around. Leaf'steamis not allowed publish theirresearch findings ahead of the peer reviewed journal article, here is some information on theircurrent research projects. I have not taken any revenue from any work relating to Dr Leaf. A critical step for improving mental health is developing non-pharmacological therapies that can treat anxiety and depression effectively without reliance on pharmacological treatments and the accompanying risks for side effects and interactions. By Dr. Caroline Leaf on September 22, 2021 In this podcast (episode #319) and blog, I talk to Kati Morton, a licensed therapist, author, and mental health advocate, about how to identify and cope with PTSD, dealing with social media trauma, reframing toxic self-talk, why things often feel like they get worse before they get better, and more! There is high-level evidence to show this to be true [26-28]. Since the early 1980's, Dr. I really didnt give them much information. Confusion of categories is what this is called. Im impressed by your humility and desire for growth and understanding. Actually, this has nothing to do with money and all to do with truth and justice. I would assume a very small number of your readers are qualified to search out all the detailed studies or analyses cited as the various references. And so are we! Leaf, but the event was promoted all over town as well as through our church. Keep up the good work buddy. Interesting study, and thanks again for the reference, but it certainly doesnt change my mind when it comes to the validity (or non-validity, as it were) of Dr Leafs teaching. Leaf Want to Be Successful? Hi Paul, thanks for your comment. WebDr. I am aware of research thats studied the anxiolytic properties of Atrial Natriuretic Peptide. 10. In this step, you will write down what you have been reflecting on in step 2. These will all affect the quality of our sleep, and how much we sleep. Sent from my iPhone. Can you also clarify why a reference from a colleague was preferred to letting Dr Leafs statements and conclusions speak for themselves? My mistake I will admit it! Thank you for offering that. You also say that Scriptures are super clear about fear and the power of our thought lives. Can you list which ones? The other thing I was wondering about is why you blame yourself for your condition? WebDr. And the settling is completely artificial. In fact, the more you build your brain, the more confident, and less anxious, you will be when faced with a challenge! Be wary of natural or alternative healers that want to sell you chelation or some herbal remedy. My question is, even she references a 1979 article and may have errors here and there, what is Dr. So, what are some aspects of this holistic approach to brain health that you can apply in your everyday life? Im interested in what she said. This about the fact she makes more money than you do and she has a bigger following and is more famous, right? E-mail us for more info and a custom quote. Since the early 1980s she has researched the Mind-Brain connection and did some of the initial research back in the late 80's showing the neuroplasticity of the brain. Id like to see the page and book where you found this quote. I dont side 100% with anyone, due to our own infallibility. Web798K Followers, 714 Following, 6,525 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Dr. Caroline Leaf (@drcarolineleaf) Historically, and as a result of all of the frightening heretical doctrine that was introduced during the middle ages, I think many Christians live a fear based life and carry that middle aged mentality to this day. Dr Leaf is not a cognitive neuroscientist. Because Dr Leaf believes that its any negative thinking pattern, or toxic thought, that can cause disease, independent of ACEs. Leaf'steamis not allowed publish theirresearch findings ahead of the peer reviewed journal article, here is some information on theircurrent research projects. Tell your pastor. Leaf was unable to connect with her son for two hours. This is my most popular post by far. As an aside, how do you factor in or out the general agreement that the things which men think are wise are plain foolishness; that spiritual things are not known by mind power?. Shout it from Facebook and other social media platforms. While Dr. Look in her eyes. So it would seem that Dr Leaf isnt teaching us to live under the peace of God, but rather the peace that our minds can purportedly generate under their own strength, something which seemingly doesnt fit well with Pauls teaching on grace (2 Corinthians 12:6-10). Happy New Year! Arnold, C. Gut feelings: the future of psychiatry may be inside your stomach. This suggests that hopeless and negative thinking may be the result of depression, rather than the cause of it. (Lewinsohn, P. M., Steinmetz, J. L., Larson, D. W., & Franklin, J. Hi there!! The data collection protocol begins with an email invitation, and non-responders are contacted up to three times by email reminders spaced by 5-7 days each. My brother is a narcissistic sociopath Leaf teaching that is harmful? Firstly, referencing a 1979 article is a sign that she relies on antiquated sources to try and make her point, which calls into question her capacity as an expert. First I find the rape story alarming. (I was reminiscing and praying about an unhappy encounter I had some years ago with an attachment theory specialist instructed by the family court, if you must know.) It was as if she were trusting in her mind over the power of prayer. Its interesting that you feel the need to resort to defence by association, and Ad Hominem dismissal as your primary counter to the points I raised. Find an event near you and reserve your spot. Information on methods of ridding the physical brain of toxins. for user demographics, treatment history, and program experience. Dr. Leafs teachings have helped me more than the drugs and the so called counselors who didnt help me at all. 6. I recently began studying Caroline Leafs research because I suspected my health conditions were a result of my thought life/stress. (Oh, and just by-the-bye most doctors I know dont just pump people full of drugs, myself included. She tested my bloodwork, as well as my micronutrient levels and also did a saliva test to check my cortisol. How would anyone be able to tell the difference if it wasnt for those pesky naysayers. And I don't have to wait long to start helping people professionally. 14. My dad had both, plus Machevelianism. And let us be open to Pitts questions- valid and in need of answers. She specializes in cognitive and metacognitive neuropsychology. As such, the numbers are too small to have any real meaning. 7. This isnt a new concept, even the CDC knows it. I envisaged that an effect similar to the placebo effect might be at work in any real-life examples of the postulated phenomenon concerned, a phenomenon which I think your own question shows you may also have in mind. Not sure they would listen as several in your audience dont. So, when it comes to our mental and physical health, it is imperative that we take a complete lifestyle approach, especially in todays world, where, for the first time in years, people are dying younger and younger from preventable, lifestyle diseases. The experimental subjects were learning how to embrace and make the anxiety and depression work for them and not against them, which is a much more sustainable approach than simply trying to numb or remove emotions and feelings completely. A final set of 71 items was selected for the initial questionnaire, and exploratory factor analysis (EFA) and confirmatory factor analyses (CFA) found 20 items nested within six factors that explained 71.9% of the overall variance. Yes, Im sure thats true. Dr. Caroline Leaf Could you compile a short document, say 10-20 pages, maybe quite dense, but coherent, possibly with references, where you would focus EXCLUSIVELY on what remains of Caroline Leafs teaching after what you have to debunk is debunked? You would never have need for medication if you were controlling your thoughts. This step is like a mental autopsy. For the benefit of Dr Leafs followers, and for the scientific and Christian community at large, I would appreciate your response. Mol Psychiatry, 2012. Perhaps you could take a lesson or 2 from Francis Schaeffer! Each communication contains a URL that participants use to gain access to the survey. And yes, the rest of it is just self-help on steroids, Christian aspirational narcissism, with a good sales pitch. I tend to be a little more cynical and try not to get caught up in group think, so this claim didnt impress me, it actually sent up a red flag. In this final episode of a series with Dr. Caroline Leaf, she illustrates her 5-step process to properly deal with emotional trauma, so you can make it through the difficult times with a healthy perspective. By Dr. Caroline Leaf on August 21, 2019. Time. It is potentially heretical to state that toxic thoughts like anger is a sin (https://cedwardpitt.com/2013/08/06/dr-caroline-leaf-serious-questions-few-answers/) or new age to suggest that You can shape your reality by the way you think (https://cedwardpitt.com/2016/10/19/the-secret-teaching-of-dr-caroline-leaf/). However, I have been to many workshops for the lay public by university professors, who have extensively referenced their information during their presentations. I read it asking What are you I about lady?!! Some easy ideas include: keeping a coloring book on your desk, doodling, writing, composing, building puzzles, or even creating new recipes! Make new friends, find a business partner, or a new career opportunity. I pray that God would guide you to such a place, and the Holy Spirit would guide you into the depths of knowledge that you desire. Do you have a different approach that works? First, it is important to note than women generally only live a few more years than men. Hobson, J.A., REM sleep and dreaming: towards a theory of protoconsciousness. When the components of CBT are considered separately, the cognitive component of cognitive behavioural therapy isnt that powerful. 5. Leaf is teaching against and it starts with the mind. And that shes full of it. She took part in some of the initial research on neuroplasticity back in the late Incredible. I take note of the fascinating subjects and wonder whether the Lord will ever allow me the opportunity to be informed by others capable of guiding me deeper. The current research study seeks to answer this call. Any contributions to this discussion from either yourself or Dr Leaf would be most welcome. This is why it is important to take the time to be creative: draw, paint, build, write, playmake time to do what you enjoy doing, and watch your brain health improve! It was bound to happen. Thanks for your comment. If our thoughts were that important, then the cognitive component of CBT would have a much stronger effect. No dietary or environmental cause has yet been identified [7]. As a doctor, a Christian, and a sufferer of mental illness, this has nothing to do with my personal ego or her ill-gotten fame, and everything to do with seeing the best outcome for the most people. In the introduction, the article mentions that CBT of any form is effective at 6 months compared with usual care, so the study is probably reflective of this broad treatment effect of any psychological intervention, which like I said, isnt particularly earth-shattering. However, alarm bells were also ringing regarding her ironclad certainty, and I could see that amongst her followers there could be casualties along the way- eg the person with cancer who strives to be in control of their mind but still sickened. As for whether Dr Leaf is qualified to teach anything its not whether she is qualified or not, its what she is actually teaching that is more important, and if you read through my book and blog posts, I think youll see my position on the quality of her teaching. And the fast talking, like a robot. I would love to see her research opened up to the rigours of peer-review and the broader scrutiny of the scientific community. A little background.. But they have to be willing to change. It is diarrhoea, and the key to its control is hygiene, sanitation, and water. [3] Hunter et al state that, diarrhoeal disease is the second most common contributor to the disease burden in developing countries (as measured by disability-adjusted life years [DALYs]), and poor-quality drinking water is an important risk factor for diarrhoea. [4]. If her theory is widely used as you say, it must have been extensively cited. And thanks for the education I hadnt heard of a flame war before but its a fairly apt description. Here are the 5 steps: 1. Dalgleish, T., The emotional brain. May Jesus bless us all in our sincere attempts to edify the saved and pre-saved!! I started viewing some of Dr. Leafs online videos.
